1. Harry and Ginny’s Kiss. In the book, it happened after a Quidditch Match with Ron and the entire Gryffindor Common Room looking on (Chapter 24). I waited the whole freaken movie to see Ron’s face, which would have been priceless. But instead they kiss in The Room of Requirement with no one to see.
2. Speaking of the Room of Requirement, when Harry puts the Advanced Potions book in there he knows where he left the book. Why? Because he placed a bust of an ugly old warlock on top of the cupboard, perched a dusty old wig and a tarnished tiara on the statue’s head* (Chapter 24). For those of you who have not read the books, any guess to who’s tiara this is? I’ll give you a hint, it’s foreshadowing to Harry’s mission in the last book. I had the same issue in Order of the Phoenix when they did not show the locket when cleaning number 12 Grimmauld Place. I guess no one cares about continuity.
3. Scrimgeour. Ok, I’m fine with cutting him out of this movie, but I think the conversation between him and the Muggle Prime Minister would have been interesting (Chapter 1).
4. Back to Harry and Ginny. In the book, they had a relationship that lasted several weeks and were public. Harry broke up with Ginny at Dumbledore’s funeral because he did not what Lord Voldermort to use her to get to him again (Chapter 30). At the end of the movie, it made it seem like their relationship was continuing. So will the kiss for Harry’s birthday not happen or not have as much significance (DH Chapter 7)?
5. The White Tomb (Chapter 30). Just cut the whole freaken last chapter out of the movie. No one is going to care about Dumbledore’s funeral. If you didn’t want to have all the actors you needed for the scene, at least show the tomb and the trio could have referenced who was in attendance at the funeral in the final scene of the movie when Hermonie told Harry they were going to help him find the Horcruxes.
Minor annoyances –
- Ginny should not have been standing next to Harry during the Quidditch trails. If anybody, it should have been Katie Bell. Remember Harry said everyone had to tryout again.
- Where was Weasley is our king?
- Snape told you he was the Half-Blood Prince, but you never found out about the name.
Now because I’m not a total cold hearted bitch, I enjoyed the following scenes:
1. Harry, Dumbledore and the Inferi – enough said.
2. Arthur Weasley’s Muggle Garage – showed his obsession nicely.
3. The Burrow – Ok, this wasn’t in the book. I thought the scene was well shot. Of course this is going to come with a caveat, Tonks used a term of endearment towards Lupin which she wouldn’t have used in this book. Speaking of them, could they have had a little more camera time since they are dying in the last movie?
4. Harry after taking Felix Felicis.
5. Ron after eating the chocolates tainted with love potion.
6. Weasleys’ Wizard Wheezes – Absolutely loved the store.
7. Ollivander’s kidnapping – This is more of I’m happy they left this in.
8. Dumbledore and Knitting Patterns – If this wasn’t left in, I probably would have thrown something at the screen.
*Wording taken from Harry Potter Lexicon